Tata Motors: The long-running battle for more than a decade between Tata Motors and the West Bengal government has finally come to an end.
Tata Motors earns ~Rs. 766 crore in compensation from the West Bengal government. plus 11% interest per annum until actual recovery.
What actually led to this legal battle?
May 18, 2006: The West Bengal government, led by Buddhadeb Bhattacharya has allotted 1,000 acres of land in Singur to Tata Motors for production of its affordable Nano car on a 99-year lease.
May to July 2006: Local farmers and political leaders, including Mamata Banerjee of the Trinamool Congress (TMC), protested the “violent” land acquisition, claiming that the nearly 6,000 displaced families were not fairly compensated.
2008: Tata Motors suspended work in Singur, and alternative sites were explored. But by this time, Tata Motors had already invested over Rs 1,000 crore in Singur.
3 October 2008: Tatas announced to move the Nano project from Singur to Sanand, Gujarat.
May 20, 2011: Mamata Banerjee became the CM of West Bengal and decided to return 400 acres of land to farmers.
June 14, 2011: The government. passed the Singur Land Rehabilitation and Development Act in Legislative Assembly to take back 400 acres of land.
June 22, 2011: Tata Motors moves to the Calcutta High Court challenging the bill. Since then, it has been argued that they did not receive fair payment for their land, and the law also removed their rights over the land.
2013: SC has asked Tata Motors to consider returning the land as they have already shifted its car plant out of Singur. However, Tata Motors has expressed its desire to retain land in Singur for its Nano project.
2016: SC set aside the land acquisition in Singur and ordered the state government to return the land to the farmers within 12 weeks.
Finally, on October 30, 2023, Tata Motors received ~Rs. 766 crore in compensation for its capital investment losses due to protests by TMC, which disrupted their Nano car project in Singur.
However, if we consider the other side of the story, the factory could have generated jobs and boosted the local economy. Instead, it ended up costing the government a major loss. They not only had to pay compensation but also lost Tata Motors from their state.
If the government’s actions were driven by a desire to regain power in the state, they may have missed a golden opportunity. Given West Bengal’s economic situation, they are struggling to create enough jobs for their people, leading many to look for higher paying opportunities elsewhere.
Written by Shivani Singh
By using the stock screener, stock heat map, portfolio backtestingand stock compare tool on the Trade Brains portal, investors gain access to comprehensive tools that enable them to identify the best stocks also updated with stock market newsand make a well-informed investment